In this Netflix original movie, I Care a Lot, the highly successful court-appointed guardian, Marla Grayson (the astonishing Rosamund Pike of “Gone Girl” fame), masterminds a scheme to being appointed guardian of wealthy elderly patients by the state court. Marla is charged with caring for the elderly who are identified by doctors as incompetent to manage their own health needs, daily living and assets.
Marla and her partner Fran (Eiza González) run a highly profitable hustle –a guardianship grift of elderly “wards of the state”. To the judge who appoints her to be caregiver, she appears as highly professional, extraordinarily articulate, and convincing in asserting her qualifications. On first appearance, the onlooker sees a measured, seemingly trustworthy advocate for eldercare. But underneath that veneer and polish, Marla is abusing a legal system by targeting wealthy seniors that actually aren’t incompetent, throwing them in care facilities and assuming absolute control of their assets. She understands this system better than most: how she can manipulate (and sometimes) bribe doctors and the courts to her advantage, essentially kidnapping the elderly, robbing them of their assets, and separating them forever from their families. She’s not a caregiver, not a caretaker. She’s neither. Marla’s an irresolute taker.
And then the “cherry”–Jennifer Peterson (Dianne Wiest in an unforgettable performance) is introduced to them by an unscrupulous physician. A “cherry” is a very wealthy old person with no family or friends to look out for them, ready for the picking. But, unexpected trouble arises when Jennifer Peterson is not who she seems. A very difficult “cherry” indeed. The predatory guardians, Marla and Fran, soon become the prey.
Unfortunately for Marla, Jennifer has an undisclosed and mysterious relationship with a powerful mobster (the delightfully malevolent Peter Dinklage from “Game of Thrones”) who will go to great lengths to protect Jennifer. He releases her from Marla’s clutches.
It’s a stomach-churning ride with a lot of venom and dismay that people assigned to be guardians for the most vulnerable may get away with highly irregular, if not criminal behavior. Resources are stretched allowing the court-appointed caregivers to conceal bad acts because they are trusted.
They come in and steal under false pretenses and strip the victim of all credibility. And Rosamund Pike’s and Peter Dinklage’s twitchy, angry staggering performances menace one another in a vicious death spiral. Until the very end of I Care a Lot the viewer is treated to unexpected twists and turns, in one traumatic scene after another.
What is most unsettling about I Care a Lot , however, is the picture it presents of eldercare: Just park them, rob them, and then move on to the next one. What seems like a con game — a gangster’s operation–is taking advantage of loopholes in the law. Watching Marla game the system to her own ends is far from comforting. The viewer has to ask: Is this amoral predator behavior really widespread? Is the eldercare/guardianship system susceptible to people like Marla and Fran to manipulate? Do some guardians stretch the rules as far as they possibly can?
Make sure your parents and grandparents are protected at all costs! I Care a Lot is a cautionary tale for all of us!
Availability: On Netflix streaming and Golden Globe-nominated for a best film.