• movie reviews
  • “The Power of the Dog”–Bad Dogs Barking Loud

“The Power of the Dog”–Bad Dogs Barking Loud

Guest Reviewer Densie Webb  (International Book Award finalist for When Robins Appear)

This slow-spun Western, sparingly based on the novel of the same name by Thomas Savage, is set on a fictional sprawling ranch in 1920s Montana (filmed in New Zealand). Directed by Jane Campion, The Power of the Dog centers on the dysfunctional, co-dependent relationship of two brothers, played by Benedict Cumberbatch (of “Sherlock Holmes”, “Dr. Strange”, and “The Imitation Game”) as Phil and Jesse Plemons (of “Breaking Bad” and “Friday Night Lights”) as George. Kirsten Dunst (“Fargo”, season 2) plays Rose, the love interest/interloper, who disrupts the established rhythm of the ranch and the brothers’ relationship, when she marries George and brings along her teenage son, Peter, (played by an other-worldly newcomer, Kodi Smith-McPhee).

In an against-type casting, Cumberbatch is an abrasive, sadistic cowboy, who cares only for his brother and grieves for another cowboy who has passed away. (One reviewer dubbed it “Brokeback Sociopath.”) Rose becomes Phil’s primary target, and the humiliation he subjects her to is uncomfortable to view.  Even his brother can’t escape Phil’s cruelty and insults. The two-hour-plus film can be excruciatingly slow, leaving viewers wondering what’s actually happening and where it’s going. It’s imbued with an ominous feeling of dread as you wait for the point of the story to be made. But it’s not until the last few scenes that it’s slowly revealed that young Peter, not Phil, is the true antagonist of the story.

The Power of the Dog is a movie that you will likely love or hate but viewers can, at the very least, appreciate the dark themes. I fall into that third category. I appreciated the acting, the cinematography, and the ability to inflict powerful feelings with a spareness of dialogue, but it was, at times, difficult to watch.

Availability:  Netflix streaming

Comments (2)

  • I was prepared for the slow pacing and was not disappointed. Still, the amazing cinematography kept my eyes enthralled while I waited for the story to push ahead, and it did. The depth and fear of loneliness in each character caused me to hold my breath at times. I’m looking forward to seeing it again as a study tool.

  • I agree with your assessment. We just saw this movie over the weekend and I was watching the clock a little hoping it would be over soon. Benedict Cumberbatch was fabulous but I expected him to be more evil at times. There was only the threat of it. And his brother needed a scene where he claimed his ground I think with a tiny bit of passion. I didn’t respect him much for being pushed around by Cumberbatch.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe to my Newsletter

* indicates required
Jan0 Posts
Feb0 Posts
Mar0 Posts
Apr0 Posts
May0 Posts
Jun0 Posts
Jul0 Posts
Aug0 Posts
Sep0 Posts
Oct0 Posts